News Analysis: The Redistricting Process Will be Fun to Watch
Apr 21, 2010 | 212 views | 0 0 comments | 1 1 recommendations | email to a friend | print

Over the next year, redistricting is going to be a very hot issue in Utah.

With the failure of the Fair Boundaries citizens’ ballot initiative to get enough signatures to place a proposal on the ballot to create an independent Redistricting Commission, the Legislature will proceed with the process as usual.

And every detail of what lawmakers do will be scrutinized very closely by the news media, watchdog groups, and the political parties, especially Utah Democrats. You can bet the majority Republicans will make the process as transparent as possible. They will invite comments and suggestions, hold public hearings across the state, and their Redistricting Committee meetings will be open to the public.

As critics like to point out, the stakeholders with the most interest in this process are state lawmakers themselves and members of Congress, because their futures depend, in part, on how the new boundaries are drawn.

There’s no question that lawmakers, both Republicans and Democrats, will be looking out for their own interests to some degree, within the legal and constitutional requirements for redistricting.

But it’s also true that lawmakers know the districts better than anyone else. They know the communities of interest and the natural boundaries. And the process will be painful. There will be winners and losers. In areas where population growth has been slow, districts will need to be combined.

Where growth has been rapid over the last decade, new districts will be created with no incumbents. In northern Utah County, some current districts have populations as much as three times as large as inner-city Salt Lake City, where little growth has occurred.

In general, redistricting may not be good news for Democrats, who represent more no- or slow-growth areas than Republicans.

And despite complaints about slicing up some counties and cities into different districts, it’s absolutely impossible to keep every community intact. Legislative districts must have the same populations, so no matter how hard legislators try, overlaying 75 House districts and 29 Senate districts onto Utah’s 245 municipalities and 29 counties, varying dramatically in population and size, is an impossibility without crossing a really lot of boundaries.

Creating new legislative districts will be an exciting process, but producing four new congressional districts will be even more intense. Plenty of debate will occur about the general parameters of the districts. Should each district have urban-rural components? Should Salt Lake County be divided into all four districts? Should politics play an obvious role with the creation of a “safe” Democratic district?

Interested parties will play with a lot of maps and numbers over the next several months. If legislative leaders follow past procedures, they will lay some of the groundwork for redistricting in the 2011 session, but the final redistricting will occur in a special session later in 2011.

That will make 2012 a very exciting election year with lots of opportunities for new entrants into the political process. Some districts will have no incumbents, and the advantages of incumbency may be lessened in other districts that cover new territory with different voters.

Hang onto your hats. The politics of redistricting over the next year will be fun to watch.             

Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
today's headlines
Local Headlines
Jun 20, 2013 | 1332 views | 0 0 comments | 5 5 recommendations | email to a friend | print

Salt Lake Tribune

Editorial: Money talks: Scientific evidence for fund limits

6 million tons of Moab tailings removed, 10 million to go

Utah lawmakers frown on allowing recall elections

House GOP OKs Swallow investigation on way to possible impeachment

Protesters say Swallow must go, public trust is shot

Senate shoots down Mike Lee's border security amendment

Lawmaker pushes registry to protect unwed dads' rights

New Utah school grades will proceed with slight tweaks

Utah's federal land, roads fights a 'wild goose chase'?

Peg McEntee: House GOP takes good first step down Swallow path

Nevada judge won't halt federal lawsuit against Jeremy Johnson

Prisons officials deny Swallow accuser faced retaliation

Becker vetoes City Council's $8 million tax hike

Deseret News

Dan Liljenquist: Three ways to restore trust in Utah A.G.'s office

Attorney General John Swallow tells House leaders 'my side of the story'

Lawmakers discuss possible tweaks to controversial school grading law

Legislative panel mulls national putative father registry

Former West Valley City Mayor Brent Anderson dies

Protesters at Capitol want Attorney General John Swallow out

House GOP stops short of starting impeachment proceedings against Swallow, votes for investigation

Salt Lake City Mayor Becker vetoes property tax increase; City Council considers override

Senators challenging White House on religious expression in military

Nevada ruling in Johnson case could bring Swallow deposition

Other

Heidi Toth: John Swallow and the public trust (Daily Herald)

House Republicans reconvening to investigate Swallow (Daily Herald)

Poll: Most Utahns want impeachment process to begin (Standard-Examiner)

Utah lawmakers vote to launch investigation of attorney general (Standard-Examiner)

John Swallow: The legal trail to impeachment (Standard-Examiner)

Obama anti-nuclear pitch in Germany draws fire from Utah Rep. Rob Bishop (Standard-Examiner)

Bomb plotter runs for mayor: Joshua Hoggan candidacy will mean primary election for Roy seat (Standard-Examiner)

Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
utah tweets
RSS Feeds
Utah policy stories feed
Policy buzz feed
Daily news highlights feed
Washington watch feed

With support from UtahWebStuff.com