Donkeys, Captains and the Kings
by Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff
Sep 04, 2012 | 864 views | 0 0 comments | 4 4 recommendations | email to a friend | print
I love poetry and like to memorize prose that inspires me. In his poem Recessional, Rudyard Kipling penned some thoughts I often quote when speaking about what should lie at the heart of public service: 

The tumult and the shouting dies—

The Captains and the Kings depart—

Still stands Thine ancient sacrifice,

An humble and a contrite heart.

Lord God of Hosts, be with us yet,

Lest we forget—lest we forget!


Growing up I loved reading and by the time I was in my teens I had gained a particular fascination for books about politics. I remember checking out a story from the Bookmobile in the summer of 1972, that would become a political classic. Taking the title of her novel Captains and the Kings from Kipling’s poem, Taylor Caldwell put her fictional protagonist, Pennsylvania Senator Rory Daniel Armagh, at the heart of the 1912 Democratic Convention battling New Jersey Governor Woodrow Wilson through multiple ballots for the presidential nomination. I was intrigued by the rags-to-riches story and fascinated, though a bit frightened, by the machination of Twentieth Century presidential politics. I was a elected a county delegate a few years later after turning eighteen, and have been involved ever since.

Last week I wrote about my fourth experience as a national convention delegate at the RNC in Tampa and shared the interesting story of the1912 GOP convention battle between incumbent President Taft and former President Teddy Roosevelt. The main issues that pitted the two former friends against each other were the debate over the extent of government regulation and the influence of corporate America on politics. These subjects continue 100 years later as major factors in debates about the proper role of government. In Tampa few protestors showed up in the wind and rain, butRomney-unified delegates cheerily waived goodbye as Ron Paul supporters left the building.

I am not attending the DNC convention in Charlotte this week but I’m watching on TV. Of course all 6,000 delegates are unified behind reelecting President Obama, but thousands of protestors showed up on the streets of Charlotte protesting economic inequality and the influence of money in politics. Indeed, the more things change the more they stay the same.

Just one week after the 1912 Convention in Chicago that resulted in the cataclysmic split between former GOP presidents over government regulation vs. corporate greed; the Democrats met in Baltimore, Maryland in a convention that itself became one the most historic events in presidential nominating history.  On the first ballot in the sweltering July heat inside the Fifth Regiment Armory, U.S. Speaker of the House Champ Clark held 440 votes compared to 324 for New Jersey Governor Woodrow Wilson. With 265 delegates voting for two other candidates, Clark was far short of the two-thirds required for the nomination. The Missouri attorney didn’t achieve a majority of delegates until the ninth ballot when the New York delegation threw in with him as directed by the Tammany machine. His bandwagon was hitched and it looked as if the long-time Congressman would become the nominee to take on incumbent President William Howard Taft. Then something extraordinary happened.

The standard bearer of the Democratic Party in the three previous presidential elections, William Jennings Bryan, alarmed by the Tammany Hall political machine he considered corrupt, spoke up and began a change that would make history. Bryan was the innovator of the stump speech and champion of the “common man,” and when he spoke, the delegates listened. He accused the Speaker of the House, with a quarter of a century in Washington, of having become the “Wall Street “candidate and the lawyer in the pocket of the wealthy upper-class. He asked the delegates instead to consider the Washington outsider who was an academic and former president of Princeton, whose Ph.D. in history and political science, Bryant argued, uniquely prepared him to be president. Delegates began to bail off of Clark’s bandwagon.  It still took two more days and a record forty-six ballots before Woodrow Wilson would receive the required two-thirds of the delegates and became the Democratic nominee and subsequently 28th President of the United States in a November landslide when Roosevelt and Taft split the Republican vote.

In her depiction of the making of a president, Taylor Caldwell focused on a group of powerful insiders who “talked only of money, the greatest of powers, the most pragmatic of common denominators. It was accepted that all other things besides money and the power of money were outside the consideration of intelligent men.” Lest we forget, one can only hope that in this election 100 years later between campaigns that will spend well north of $1 Billion, there will be less of captains and kings and more of Kipling’s ancient sacrifice.
Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
today's headlines
Local Headlines
Jun 19, 2013 | 12488 views | 0 0 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print

Salt Lake Tribune

Op-ed: Hatch amendments hurt

Wanted: West Valley City police chief who can restore public trust

Obamacare moves to forefront in immigration debate

Gun lobbyist seeks restoration of firearms rights

Swallow’s fate in House GOP’s hands Wednesday

Charter-school pioneer discusses innovative ed movement at Utah conference

Utah regulators asked to reconsider power plant pollution solution

Paul Rolly: School bus vandalism yields an unlikely culprit

Weber voters to decide $45 million library bond

In veto-proof vote, Salt Lake City Council OK’s $8M tax increase

Wharton: Selfish reasons to oppose Nevada water deal

Report says too many teachers, too little quality; Utah educators question study

Herbert not budging on Snake Valley deal

Family steps up with $4 million to rescue Capitol Theatre project

Granite schools will cut staff to make up budget deficit

Deseret News

Op-ed: People deserve rights at our borders

Editorial: A darkening cloud

Editorial: Limit the power of the Antiquities Act

Milestone reached in removing Moab tailings

Utah Technology Council touts STEM education for Utah’s economic future

Report: Teacher training in U.S. an 'industry of mediocrity'

Governor Herbert says he won't change his mind on Snake Valley water sharing agreement

Salt Lake City approves 13.8 percent tax hike despite mayor's threat to veto

Washington Post writer: Mitt Romney lost because he's Superman; modern voters prefer Batman

Impeachment investigation 'highly likely,' House majority leader says

Other

Mark Saal: In Utah we are constantly fighting the war on weeds (Standard-Examiner)

Emissions could be cut (Park Record)

Hi-ho, Silver: Western governors are away to Park City (Park Record)

Logan Municipal Council to conduct public hearing on $129M proposal for 2014 budget (Logan Herald Journal)

Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
utah tweets
RSS Feeds
Utah policy stories feed
Policy buzz feed
Daily news highlights feed
Washington watch feed

With support from UtahWebStuff.com