There are just seven days to go until the 2016 election. Here are five ways I think election day 2016 will play out in Utah.
1. The race for Utah’s six electoral votes is going to be tight all the way to November 8.
Evan McMullin has a real shot at carrying Utah in November. As the media has covered ad-infinitum, he would be the first third-party candidate to win a state since George Wallace in 1968.
McMullin has a lot of momentum and is generating enthusiasm among a lot of Mormons and Republicans who want someone other than Donald Trump to vote for.
But, he doesn’t have this thing wrapped up by a long shot. Only one survey has shown him in the lead.
We all know Donald Trump is not wildly popular in Utah. Yet, he’s still pulling 30-35% in the polls.
If I had to make a guess about what’s going to happen on Tuesday, I think Trump will eke out a very close win over McMullin.
2. A Clinton will finish third in a presidential race in Utah for the second time.
Hillary Clinton is not going to win Utah. In fact, she’ll probably suffer the same fate as her husband did in 1992, when he finished in third place behind George H.W. Bush and Ross Perot.
McMullin is clearly dividing the vote in Utah, and Democrats are hoping that Clinton will benefit from that division and snatch an unlikely victory in the Beehive State.
Not gonna happen.
The only suspense left here is whether Hillary Clinton will get a larger share of the vote than Bill did 24 years ago. Bill finished with 24.7% of the vote. Polling has Clinton between 25 and 30%. If Hillary finishes with more than 25%, it’s a moral victory.
3. Republicans are going to sweep the big races in Utah.
All of the statewide races, as well as the Congressional contests, will go to the GOP.
The only race with any suspense is the 4th Congressional District rematch between Republican Mia Love and Democrat Doug Owens. Polling shows Love has a lead between 8 and 13-points. That lead will tighten, but Love should maintain her lead.
I think back to the rematch between Jim Mathson and Republican John Swallow. Matheson barely defeated Swallow in 2002. The next cycle, everyone was expecting a knock-down drag-out fight, but Matheson trounced Swallow easily by 11 points. Love should get the win this year.
4. Evan McMullin may help down-ballot Republicans this year.
Utah Democrats are absolutely giddy about their prospects for picking up seats in the legislature. In fact, Democratic chair Peter Corroon has said publicly they expect to gain up to 10 seats this year.
Democrats are counting on those Republican voters who are repulsed by Donald Trump to either not vote at all or consider Democrats this year on the ballot.
Now that Evan McMullin is a viable option, many Republicans who might stay home because of Trump can now cast their ballot for McMullin, and then consider other Republcians down the ballot.
That’s not good news for Democrats.
Sure, early voting so far has favored Democrats, but Republicans (and Republican-leaning independents) in Utah outnumber them by a vast margin. Evan McMullin makes those voters more likely to cast a ballot when they otherwise may not have because of Trump.
5. Democrats will make some gains on Utah’s Capitol Hill, but they will be minimal.
Sorry Democrats. You’re not going to break the Republican supermajority in the Utah Legislature. You might pick up a seat or two, possibly three, in the House, but that’s probably it.
There are three seats Democrats lost by a handful of votes on election night in 2014. Two of those races favor the Republican this time around.
Rep. Sophia DiCaro is a rising star in the Republican party. In 2014, she defeated Democrat Larry Wiley by 195 votes. She should have an easier time this election.
In District 30, Republican Fred Cox defeated Democrat Mike Lee by 47 votes. This time around Mike Winder is the Republican nominee and is a much stronger campaigner than former Rep. Fred Cox. He should win by a wider margin this time around.
There are a few races where Democrats have a good chance at upsetting incumbent Republicans, but nowhere near the 8-10 they’re hoping for.
