The near invincibility of being a Utah legislator continued in the 2016 elections, with by far most exits the result of retirements rather than being voted out of office.
Only 9.3 percent of the 75 House races saw either party delegates, primary voters or general election voters choosing to make a switch.
Not one of the 15 state Senate seats saw a change in either political party or incumbents losing – the only changes came through voluntary retirements.
So the generational trend of Utah legislators – whether Republicans or Democrats – staying as long as they wish in their part-time, law-making, budget-setting jobs continues.
All 75, two-year-term House members are up in each general election year.
Half of the four-year-term, 29 senators are up each election cycle in Utah.
And the 104-member Legislature – controlled by Republicans since 1980 – has proven reluctant to electoral change.
That is not to say there is not turnover.
There is.
But it comes mostly through death and retirement, not at the ballot box.
Early, unofficial (but complete) returns from Tuesday night’s elections show:
— There will be 17 new faces in the 2017-2018 Legislature, including one former legislator now back in office.
So 22.6 percent of House will be freshmen. This is about what recent House elections have seen.
And only 9.3 percent is because an incumbent seeking re-election lost.
The 29-member Senate finds only a 13.7 percent turnover. But two of those are House incumbents moving to the upper body via retirements – former Reps. Jake Anderegg, R-Lehi, and Don Ipson, R-St. George who easily won election Tuesday.
And Sen.-elect Gregg Buxton, R-Roy, served in the House years ago, so he is not a newbie, either.
The only new Senate face will be Republican Dan Hemmert – who won the GOP appointment after Sen. Al Jackson resigned to move back East. And Hemmert, no surprise, won the Orem-based seat on Tuesday.
The House’s “new face” number could change when the official canvasses take place in about two weeks – there are a handful of close elections there and the final vote counts could make a difference.
As of Tuesday night, we see:
— Only four races saw incumbents losing at the ballot box:
— Rep. Sophia DiCaro, R-West Valley, lost to Democratic Elizabeth Weight in District 30. That loss was by 270 votes out of 4,822 counted.
This was one of the three districts that flipped at the 2014 canvass, so DiCaro still has a chance of final victory.
— In District 44, Rep. Bruce Cutler, R-Murray, lost Tuesday to Democrat Christine Passey (who ran against him two years ago), by 226 votes out of 9,334 counted.
This was another of the three flipped races of 2014; watch for a close final tally at canvass.
— Perhaps the biggest surprise result Tuesday was the defeat of Rep. LaVar Christensen, R-Draper. He was beaten by Democrat Suzanne Harrison by 195 votes out of District 32’s 10,895 ballots.
Christensen has had a mottled legislative career — in the House, out to run unsuccessfully for Congress, back in, losing a race, and now out of office again – at least until the canvass.
An attorney/developer by profession, Christensen has led some of the moral/archconservative House battles, known for his long, often technical, floor debates.
— Outside of Salt Lake County (in a bit of a surprise result), long-time Rep. Brad King, D-Price, lost to Republican Christine Watkins by 369 votes.
Watkins was a member of House Democratic leadership four years ago. She lost to a Republican after redistricting, changed parties, lost the GOP nomination in House 60 two years ago only to win the nomination this year.
There were 13,239 total votes counted Tuesday in District 69, so that race could flip at canvass, also. But as it stands Watkins is back in the House, on the other side of the aisle, and really can’t be called a freshman lawmaker.
Now, several GOP House incumbents this year lost at convention or primary – so while there will be new faces there, the party still held those seats Tuesday.
Back in political office is former West Valley City Mayor Mike Winder, who defeated Rep. Fred Cox, R-West Valley, in the Salt Lake County GOP convention, and won District 30 handily Tuesday.
One of the longest-serving House members, Rep. Mel Brown, R-Coalville, a former speaker, lost a primary to Morgan County Councilman Logan Wilde (by eight votes).
Brown sued before the Utah Supreme Court, asking that some late ballots be counted. He lost on a technicality and decided not to refile. Wilde won the heavily-GOP district Tuesday and is one of the new faces.
Two retiring House Republicans tried the old “switch-a-roo,” not filing for re-election on the final filing day, with their picked successor filing instead – with mixed results.
Syracuse City Councilman Karianne Lisonbee won retiring Rep. Curt Oda’s House District 14.
But Rep. Johnny Anderson’s first pick didn’t win the GOP nomination, then the ultimate Republican nominee, Macade Jensen, lost to Democrat Karen Kwan by 493 votes (7,663 total) Tuesday night in District 34.
Again, final canvass numbers may change some of these races.
But for now, once again, if you win an office in the Utah Legislature you can count on holding it until you drop dead on the Chamber floor, or decide to retire.
