Hughes set to take on Utah high school athletic transfer issue

UHSAA LogoUtah House Speaker Greg Hughes, a guy you really don’t want questioning how you’re running your operations, is turning his eye this session to the Utah High School Activities Association.

And it may end up that the other guy in the Utah Capitol who you really, really, don’t want looking at your organization, State Auditor John Dougall, could be looking the same direction.

Hughes, R-Draper, along with House Majority Whip Frances Gibson, R-Mapleton, will be looking to set up in state law procedures for the association to determine who can transfer to different schools to play sports.

This may sound like a rather boring topic.

It isn’t.

For thousands of high school boys and girls each year this is life-changing, and their parents – the voters in legislative races – are critically concerned.

Hughes says he’s working drafting the bill now. And it will be carried by Gibson, a former high school football coach and BYU football player, adds the speaker.

Hughes, who at one time sat on the board of a charter school his three children attended, says it appears to him some games are being played in how some students are given transfers to play sports, and others are not.

And he doesn’t like that.

“Heavens, yes, this will be controversial,” said Hughes – who has a well-earned reputation of NOT backing away from controversial subjects.

“I don’t like what’s been going on. You (the parents) get an attorney from a ritzy part of town, and you can go” to another high school and play your sport.

He believes there has been “prejudice, hubris and arrogance” in how the transfer process has been dealt with before.

“I don’t like the climate in which these kids’ fates have been decided. There needs to be a better way,” says Hughes, who said he has held several meetings previously with the association and its lobbyists, and didn’t like the way his and others’ concerns were handled.

Now, folks can be reasonable – and Hughes says he has every hope that setting up a proper procedure for handling these transfers can be in that area.

Or maybe Dougall may want to take a look at the association? The speaker asked.

Yes, the association doesn’t take tax dollars directly, says Hughes. But their employees are covered under the state health program, and they belong to the state’s retirement plan – more than enough to get Dougall’s foot in the door if need be.

But, Hughes says, right now all is good. All sides are invited to participate in the drafting of the bill, and all opinions are welcomed.

“People have gotten too wound up on the specific rules” – which kids can transfer to play sports, which cannot.

Hughes says of 2,000 official transfer requests coming last year, only 9 kids were turned down.

Ok, but those decisions are held in private, says Hughes.

He wants the association hearings to be open to the public under GRAMA rules, and decisions appealable to some other entity than the association itself.

He suggests that the State School Board, elected by the people, would be a good place for appeals to be decided.

“This will be controversial because we are talking about changing” the power “of people’s turf,” Hughes told UtahPolicy Monday afternoon.

People defend their turf.

“I want a fair, transparent process” of children transferring from one school to another, with the clear intention of playing a sport.

More Stories
Business Headlines 6-26-15