budget5

Analysis: How to Propose a Tax Hike for Public Schools

budget5Get ready for an 18-month sophisticated political and public relations campaign to convince you, dear reader, to raise you own personal Utah state income taxes.

Actually, the effort has been ongoing for more than two years. But much of the talking has been behind the scenes, and not on the front burner of statewide political debate.

The effort is now clear, after a press conference this past Tuesday by a new, combined pro-K-12 education group of local big-hitters – called Our Schools Now.

UtahPolicy first reported on this new group (although it did not have a name then) in August.

The new group is made up of Education First Utah and Prosperity 2020 supporters, among others.

OSN is slightly different. It’s not formally endorsed by the Salt Lake Chamber, although Chamber President Lane Beattie (a former state Senate president) is on the OSN main board.

How Our Schools Now formed, evolved and moved around the 2016 state and legislative elections is a good example of smart political maneuvering.

OSN’s ultimate goal, as outlined in this press release, is to gather the more than 100,000 voter signatures on a petition that would go before voters in the 2018 general election.

That petition (we haven’t seen a copy yet) would have Utahns raise their personal income tax rate by 7/8th of 1 percent, from the current 5% to 5.875%.

That would bring an extra $750 million more into K-12 public education funding each year.

We won’t go through all of the good reasons for the tax hike here. Those debates will take place many times over before the 2018 vote (if the signatures can be collected).

Rather, here is a political analysis of how this group got itself going and stayed out of the big political fights of 2016.

For some time pro-education advocates have been thinking about how to get more money into public education.

However, from the start, it appeared that neither GOP Gov. Gary Herbert nor conservative Republicans who control the Legislature would go along.

Herbert faced two elections over six years after succeeding former Gov. Jon Huntsman in early 2009.

And Herbert planned to run again for (what he’s said) is his final term in 2016.

Without a powerful governor to back a general income tax hike, there’s little chance GOP legislators would lead that charge.

Even though Education First supporters backed the 7/8th of 1 percent increase several years ago, that tax hike was never introduced in the Legislature – not even by a Democrat who would know such a measure would fail.

So Education First and some folks in Prosperity 2020 went back to the political drawing board.

They knew they had to stay out of the 2016 elections – making Herbert or other gubernatorial candidates take a definite stand on the 7/8th percent increase wasn’t going to work.

When the 7/8th proposal first became public, UtahPolicy (the only group doing regular polling in Utah) naturally put that question on polls conducted by Dan Jones & Associates, Utah’s premiere pollster whose results would be respected by political and civic leaders.

That polling shows consistent support (in the 66 percentile range) for such a tax hike for public schools.

The general feeling is the Legislature or governor won’t move to increase taxes in an election year. So the 2016 Legislature was out.

Herbert faced an archconservative in Jonathan Johnson in the GOP primary. Johnson wasn’t going to support any tax hike, so Herbert couldn’t, either.

Once Herbert won the June GOP primary he was assured victory in November, and while his Democratic challenger Mike Weinholtz favored a tax hike for public schools, the 2016 Legislature was already over, and Herbert couldn’t have pushed it even if he wanted to. So he didn’t.

In fact, some Education First folks hoped that following the November election Herbert would back the 7/8th. 

But he couldn’t do that in his soon-to-be-released 2016-2017 budget recommendation – because he would have had to run on that tax hike in 2016. That would be politically dishonest.

Herbert has told UtahPolicy that there will be no tax hike for education in his upcoming budget. And without the governor on board – if not leading the way– it’s unlikely the part-time GOP lawmakers would take up the cause in the January general session.

So with 2017 out of the picture, and with 2018 an election year for lawmakers, Education First folks were in a bind.

They could wait until 2019 and hope Herbert, with one year left in his last term and perhaps seen as a lame duck, and the GOP legislative majority would act.

But that is an iffy proposition. Such a strategy could lead to further stalemate, with a few GOP legislative leaders looking to run for governor in 2020 and not risking any general tax hike support.

So a go-it-alone strategy had to come forward – either run a citizen referendum question on the 2018 ballot – asking citizens if they favored an income tax hike for schools — or go the whole hog and push for a tax hike by voters that year.

In the end, the OSN leaders decided not to waste $1 million on a signature-gathering effort only to ask a non-binding question on the 2018 ballot.

Better to just go for a direct citizen initiative petition that would raise the tax with voter approval.

So how to get that started?

— First, you wait until after the November 2016 election to say or do anything in public. You don’t want your effort harmed by gubernatorial or legislative candidates afraid of angering voters.

Then get a well-respected, independent group to take a look at long-term Utah education funding.

An unbiased report would provide the critical facts that your signature-gathering/ballot PR effort would rely on.

That report came on Monday – one day ahead of the OSN public press conference.

The Utah Foundation report can be found here.

And it is bleak – as the OSN folks knew it would be since these numbers have generally been known (or guessed at) for some time.

Utah public schools are getting $1.2 billion LESS annually today than if lawmakers hadn’t given a myriad of income tax, property tax and special interest tax breaks over the last 20 years – which directly or indirectly harmed public school funding.

(While not naming him directly, the foundation report also shoots down Herbert’s public school claim to fame: That he’s marshaled $1.8 billion in new money toward schools in the last five years. He has, but inflation and public school student growth – 10,000 new kids a year – has eaten it up, leaving only an average of $22 million in new cash each academic year. A mere pittance.)

So, OSN has the polls (and their results) in their favor.

They have an unbiased education funding report in their favor.

And they will now go forward not depending on Herbert and GOP legislators to get this done for them.

Our Schools Now is ready to go, with a well-planned political campaign ahead.

It is lead by smart folks, who’ve been in the public arena before.

It has big money behind it.

But these political questions remain: Who is going to oppose the tax hike? How will they organize? How will the opposition raise funds?

Will some tax-hike compromise with lawmakers/Herbert be reached beforehand, as was the case with Count My Vote and SB54?

Get ready for an interesting political battle ahead, with Utah school children’s education on the block.

More Stories
CYBER 24 podcast episode 17: Tips to thwart tax fraud and looking out for skimmers