bernick mug
Bob Bernick

Bob Bernick’s Notebook: Who Will Oppose a Tax Hike for Schools?

Bob BernickUtah’s Republican legislators don’t like citizen initiative petitions.

In fact, if the state Constitution didn’t guarantee such a process to bypass the Legislature to create new laws, I’d guess the GOP-controlled House and Senate would repeal any statute that allowed for such a challenge to the lawmakers’ supreme power.

But citizen initiative petitions are in the Constitution.

Over the last several decades that I’ve reported on the 104-member, part-time Legislature, the Republican majority has several times taken steps to further restrict citizens’ ability to run voter-approved initiatives successfully.

At one point someone sued, and the Utah Supreme Court changed the manner of petition signatures, and sharply warned the Legislature not to further restrict the petition process. The justices said the requirements imposed by lawmakers were getting close to making it too hard to gather the signatures, and thus thwart the constitutionally guaranteed right.

All of this history comes into play now as a new pro-education group – Our Schools Now – this week announced it would attempt to gather petition signatures to raise the state’s personal income tax rate from 5 percent to 5.875 percent – or 7/8th of 1 percent.

All income taxes go to public or higher education.

That will bring an extra $750 million into public K-12 schools each year, and drag Utah up from last place in the nation in per-pupil spending.

Utahns, today, pay less of a percent of their personal income for public schools than they did 20 years ago – a total of $1.8 billion. That’s the finding of a new Utah Foundation education funding over time study released this week.

You can read the Utah Foundation education funding report here.

I encourage you to do so. Every Utahn needs to know this information, which will be critical to the OSN petition effort and the general election vote in 2018.

In the meantime, it will be interesting to see who comes forward to oppose this tax hike petition.

Who will say our schools are doing fine as they are, and our kids don’t need more money into a system that is overstrained, overcrowded, and where too many children don’t get the individual attention they need to succeed in the classroom.

Who will be the face of the Grinch who stole our children’s future?

Good luck with that.

One political compromise may be sought by conservative GOP lawmakers who don’t want the 7/8th to hit all at one time: Some kind of phase-in income tax rate hike that automatically takes place over several years.

That could blunt the OSN petition movement (and save its backers upwards of $1 million – the cost of running a successful statewide petition drive).

If for example, GOP lawmakers passed a law in the 2017 session that increased the personal income tax rate by 1/4th of 1 percent over four years, that would still get you where you need to go by 2020, and likely would be more appealing to taxpayers and the part-time legislative politicians.

GOP Gov. Gary Herbert releases his recommended 2016-2017 budget this coming Wednesday. He has already told UtahPolicy that there will be no education tax hike in that plan.

But lawmakers over the last 20 years have been ignoring the governor’s budget recommendation – they don’t even present it in their budget subcommittees anymore.

And figuring out a proposed tax hike for schools is relatively easy to see – you just raise the rate, calculate how much more money that brings into the Weighted Pupil Unit – which in turn lets you see how much more each of the state’s 41 school districts will get.

You certainly could restrict how that new money could be spent – even give each public school, its parents, teachers, and administrators the power to decide how that new money would be expended in each school.

Real power in local control – that’s a fine selling point.

We’ll see how all of this plays out.

But the OSN folks are smart, they have big money behind them, and they have the force of a citizen tax hike movement in their hands.

Finally, congratulations to two political reporter colleagues – Matt Canham and Robert Gehrke of The Salt Lake Tribune.

Canham has been named managing editor over all news operations – from just a regular reporter to a top dog.

And Gehrke, who has covered politics in Utah for some time – becomes a columnist, what is considered a promotion in our business.

Editors at the Trib will be hard-pressed to replace these two political reporters. Good luck to all.

More Stories
Business headlines 11-20-20