While it may have been a bit unclear in his State of the State address Wednesday night, under questioning from the media Friday afternoon, Gov. Gary Herbert said he favors tearing down the so-called Zion Curtain and expects it to happen this legislative session.
And, Herbert said, he did call leaders of the LDS Church to let them know that is what he intends to do.
Mormon leaders never endorse changes in Utah liquor law; but they have opposed “reforms” in the past – killing those attempts in the Legislature, which is around 80 faithful, tithe-paying Saints.
Herbert’s support is, at least for now, different from several GOP Senate leaders, who Thursday said they don’t favor repealing the law which says newly-licensed restaurants must install a 7-foot barrier which shields patrons from seeing alcohol drinks being prepared and wine and beer dispensed.
Nicknamed the Zion Curtain by the media, because Mormons believe Utah is Zion – or the Promised Land – in recent Legislatures attempts to repeal the wall have failed.
Herbert repeated that the change would come with a compromise – “that is politics” – and new or enhanced measures adopted to deter underage drinking; over-drinking, or binging; and DUI enforcement and prevention.
So while the media (yours truly included) seem to focus on the curtain, there will be more important alcohol reforms coming this session, the governor believes.
The main alcohol bill is going to be sponsored by House Majority Leader Brad Wilson, R-Kaysville, who, like most other members of the Legislature, does not, in fact, drink alcohol himself.
Herbert said that the curtain law has several problems and is not uniformly enforced:
— First, older licensed restaurants were grandfathered in and didn’t have to erect the wall. That now appears unfair.
— Secondly, there is no hard evidence that Herbert has seen that the wall is, actually, effective – that it discourages underage restaurant patrons (those under 21) from trying to or starting to, drink.
What Herbert didn’t say is that while Utah, in reality, may no longer have weird liquor laws, many outsiders and visitors still believe we do.
And seeing the wall hiding the mixing of drinks just reinforces the belief that Utah is not a welcoming or hospitable place to visit.
Replacing the wall will be a trade-off, said Herbert, “the compromise of politics,” and more effective alcohol abuse measures will be taken.
“I expect this to happen this session,” said Herbert
But Thursday, Senate Majority Whip Stuart Adams, R-Layton, told reporters that he doesn’t see the wall falling this session.
In fact, Adams said he doesn’t see support for that among GOP senators.
The wall was part of an LDS-agreed-to reform package of about a decade ago, which saw a major change: The end of private clubs in Utah in favor of “liquor-by-the-drink” in bars.
In addition, in restaurants drinks could be mixed for patrons by serving staff, and in alcohol proportions normally seen around the country.
While currently-licensed restaurants could have bar areas where patrons could see the dispensing of drinks, wine, and beer, new restaurants would have to have a barrier up to shield patrons from the evil brew.
A bit of history: As a young Apostle, Gordon B. Hinckley (who became a much beloved LDS Church president), was put in charge of the Church’s fight against a 1968 liquor-by-the-drink citizen petition.
The petition failed. And it was generally assumed that the LDS Church would never agree to liquor-by-the-drink while Hinckley was still alive.
Hinckley passed away in 2008, and soon after that came the “reform” of Utah liquor laws that included the Zion Curtain compromise with a new church hierarchy.

