bernick mug
Bob Bernick

Bob Bernick’s notebook: Ballot battle

Bob BernickJust remember this, dear reader: No matter what the bosses of the Utah Republican Party say or do, they don’t have total control who gets on their party’s taxpayer-paid-for primary ballot.

Simple as that.

But party bosses can decide who may be a Republican in Utah – they can kick someone out of the party, they can sanction a party member, they can even campaign AGAINST a candidate who is on the primary ballot under the Republican Party banner — even campaign against someone who becomes the party’s official nominee.

But the bosses can’t keep anyone off of the GOP primary ballot if they go through the SB54 petition signature-gathering route.

That was the basis of several GOP lawsuits against SB54 – and both the Utah Supreme Court and a federal court judge ruled that the dual pathway law is constitutional.

Why do I make what should be such a plain denouncement?

Well, for one thing, a Salt Lake Tribune political columnist is now in a micturating match with GOP state chairman James Evans over the issue.

Here is Robert Gehrke’s column.

Here is Evans’ reply press release.

20170209 GOP Gehrke Response

Evans told UtahPolicy on Thursday that he sees “no appetite” by the party’s governing Central Committee to change its neutrality policy – won’t oppose any GOP candidate should he get on the primary ballot only via the petition-gathering route.

Mark Thomas, head of state elections, reminds folks that SB54 does several things, including allowing parties to decide for themselves if they are a “qualified political party” – QPP – or a “registered political party.”

By the end of September this year, all parties must tell the State Elections Office what kind of party they will be in 2018. And to be a QPP you have to let candidates go through the petition route, convention route, or both. A “registered” party can ONLY have candidates go the petition route – bypassing convention delegates all together.

So, should the GOP bosses decide to be a QPP – and keep the convention route option — but then put in place bylaws or procedures that violate SB54, what then?

Thomas says we’ll have to wait and see.

But it could be the state GOP is denied QPP status, and all of its candidates must go the petition route.

Or even that the state GOP won’t have any candidates running on the ballot under the Republican Party banner.

Evans says none of those things will happen.

But wouldn’t that be interesting? How the heck would voters know whom to vote for in minor races, like the Utah Legislature – where party I.D. is so important?

In any case, the more the Republican Party bosses mess around with SB54, the greater chance that some candidates will just go the petition route, or just run as political independents.

Here’s something to watch: Let’s say the party bosses say you have to pass a “purity” test, have to go only through their convention (not the petition route), or they will denounce you or even campaign against you.

I’m guessing a well-known GOP candidate like former Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. will run for the U.S. Senate as an independent. That way he stays out of the GOP mess all together in 2018.

What does Sen. Orrin Hatch do?

Well, one would think Hatch would take the petition route and the convention route at the same time. But what if Hatch won’t take the purity test?

What if party rules say he can’t take the petition route to the primary and still be as recognized Republican candidate?

Does Hatch really want to risk losing in the 2018 state GOP convention and being out of office?

That happened to the late-Sen. Bob Bennett in 2010, didn’t it.

The state Utah Republican Party CAN’T keep a GOP candidate off the taxpayer-paid-for primary ballot, should he qualify via the petition route.

But they may mess up the party even more – and alienate all kinds of voters – by kicking people, candidates or not, out of the party for not being “real” Republicans.

We’ll see.

More Stories
Local Headlines 11-19-13