Effort to create runoff elections is over for 2017

Utah State CapitolIt looks like the effort to address the “plurality issue” in Utah’s primary elections is dead for 2017.

Sen. Curt Bramble, R-Provo, tried to set up a mail-only runoff election in primary contests with four or more candidates and none of them get 35% of the vote.

That was an attempt to address concerns raised by the Utah Republican Party in the wake of the SB54 compromise, which allowed candidates to get on the primary ballot by gathering signatures instead of through the convention system. That caused a lot of heartburn for the Utah GOP, the worry being that multiple candidates could lead to someone winning a party nomination with less than 50% of the vote. The party filed numerous lawsuits against SB54,

“The Utah GOP told us if we addressed the plurality issue, they would withdraw their lawsuit against SB54,” says Bramble. “We agreed and introduced a bill that does just that.”

Initially, the Utah GOP Central Committee voted to drop their lawsuit, but then reversed course and voted to revive the lawsuit and actively oppose Bramble’s bill. Essentially, lawmakers called their bluff, and the Utah GOP just went ahead and did what they were planning on doing in the first place.

After passing the Senate, the bill is set for a House committee hearing on Thursday. Bramble tells UtahPolicy.com that the runoff election will be stripped out of the bill before it moves forward. One wonders how much patience lawmakers have left for the hardliners in their own party who are hellbent on killing SB54. Every single accommodation offered by lawmakers has been met with resistance and hostility. 

The new SB114 will move the candidate filing period to the first week in January for candidates who plan to gather signatures to get on the ballot. The current filing period will remain following the annual legislative session for candidates who intend to go the convention route only. Additionally, candidates who use the signature gathering route will also be able to utilize the convention route.

Rep. Dan McCay, R-Riverton, is pursuing a similar course with the recently introduced HB450. That bill restricts a candidate’s petition-gathering declaration time to five working business days the first of January.

Currently, said McCay – the House co-sponsor of the SB54 compromise back in 2014 – a candidate has from Jan. 1 to mid-March to declare whether he is going to gather voter signatures to get on his party’s primary ballot.

Other candidates for the post “must take time each day to look up on the web to see if they have a petition candidate running against them,” said McCay.

That is time-consuming and basically unfair – for convention-only candidates just have a week to declare their candidacy, starting the day after the Legislature ends in early March.

What’s good for one set of candidates – just one week to formally file their candidacy – should be good for another group of candidates – those that are taking either the petition route.

“We shouldn’t have to be wondering for three months whether we have a (petition) candidate or not” running against them, said McCay.

More Stories
Situational awareness – February 1, 2018