democrat1

Utah Democrats may try to keep candidates from running to avoid primary elections

Utah’s Democratic Party leaders are considering a plan to cut down on the number of contested primary races they’ll have next year, hopefully leading to more election wins in November.

UtahPolicy.com has obtained an email circulating among the Party’s executive staff that suggests that Utah Democrats should hold meetings with groups that may be thinking about recruiting candidates for legislative races. Those groups include unions, issue groups, and consultants, hoping they can get on the same page when throwing their support behind candidates. 

Essentially, the party is hoping to pre-determine which candidates stand for election before delegates and voters get a say at the convention or in a primary election.

The email from Party Treasurer Crystal Young-Otterstrom says, in part, that the party should bring those organizations together to lay out a plan to make it easier for candidates to avoid primary challenges or fights at the conventions.

“Start with a speech like, ‘we recognize that a lot of groups are in the recruiting business and some of y‘all aren’t going to want to work together, some want to keep their aces in their pocket, some of you hate each other, etc blah blah, but that’s how we’ve always operated as a party and it’s clearly not working for us because we keep loosing (sic) elections. So let’s at least attempt to work together for once and try to avoid a few primaries and convention battles.'” 

20171023 Dem email

When reached for comment, Young-Otterstrom said she offered up the plan to foster cooperation among interested parties. She did not dispute the authenticity of the email.

“I was simply suggesting that we bring as many people and entities together as we can in the spirit of cooperation,” said Otterstrom-Young in an email. “I mean, heck, even LDS Dems, and the Progressive Caucus want to recruit together! That’s cooperation! If the GOP in this state is entitled to work with Koch money, we should at least be able to ask the AFL-CIO who they would like to see run.”

The strategy is a sound one from a party standpoint. If you reduce the number of bruising primary elections, which can drain resources away from already overmatched Democratic candidates. Better instead to marshall money and volunteers for the general election against the Republican candidate. It also cuts down on the number of “fringe” candidates who can cause headaches for more mainstream Democrats.

But, it’s a double-edged sword, too because it can look unseemly to have the party colluding with groups to decide who can and cannot run for office.

Party Chair Daisy Thomas did not respond to requests for comment.

Several of the groups mentioned in the email circulating at the top of the Utah Democratic Party confirm to UtahPolicy.com that they have been contacted by Democrats to meet about candidate recruitment strategy.

In her defense of the pre-election culling of candidates, Young-Otterstrom took an opportunity to swipe at the Utah GOP.

“Look, the GOP builds coalitions to raise money, because they are the party of outside donations. The Democrats build coalitions for the sake of ideas because we are the party of ideas. We value democracy and hearing all ideas, which is what I was suggesting we do.”

More Stories
Owens co-sponsors Congressional Gold Medal Bill recognizing the Defenders of Ukraine