Proposed constitutional change would give lawmakers the power to call themselves into a special session

Utah lawmakers – who now can only be called into a special session by the governor – would have the power to call themselves into such sessions and set their own agendas under a constitutional amendment introduced Friday.

As reported previously by UtahPolicy.com, House Majority Leader Brad Wilson, R-Kaysville, is taking on the sensitive issue. Gov. Gary Herbert opposes giving the Legislature that power.

Wilson filed HJR18 on Friday, which allows for lawmakers to come into a special session with a two-thirds vote of both the House and Senate.

The amendment this session must pass by two-thirds in both bodies, and if it does then voters will decide whether to adopt it in the November general election.

The Utah governor has no say in constitutional amendments – he can’t veto them. But he can, of course, speak against them.

Herbert has opposed publicly the idea that lawmakers can call themselves into a special session, adding that things have worked well for over 100 years and so why mess with it.

This balance of power issue comes over Herbert’s refusal to call the GOP-dominated Legislature into a special session last spring after it became known that U.S. Rep. Jason Chaffetz, R-Utah, was going to resign.

The Legislature had never passed a law outlining how a special U.S. House election would be conducted – except to say in statute that the governor would call such an election.

So Herbert and Lt. Gov. Spencer Cox, the state’s official election officer, following current election law, set up a dual-path candidate process to replace Chaffetz. That ultimately resulted in Republican 3rd District delegates’ pick being defeated by signature-gathering candidate John Curtis in a primary election. Curtis won the general election and now sits in the seat.

A number of conservative lawmakers really didn’t like that – a few of them may have wanted to run for the seat, or they wanted the delegates’ pick to be the GOP nominee – and the sure winner in the general election held last November.

Thus the amendment – which would allow two-thirds of lawmakers to call themselves into a special session in case of:

 “…a persistent fiscal crisis, war, natural disaster, or emergency in the affairs of the State…”

“Emergency” is not defined.

So it would be up to the Senate president and House speaker – who must jointly issue a proclamation under which the polling of members will take place – to decide what an “emergency” really is.

Presumably, the Legislature wishing to adopt the election rules for a mid-term U.S. House vacancy election would be such an emergency – since that is what started this whole Herbert/lawmaker fight to begin with.

The amendment says lawmakers can be in special session only 10 days, and leaders can’t call for a special session within 30 days after the general session ends.

The first condition is to stop leaders from calling lawmakers into long special sessions as a way to pay them more money for their part-time jobs.

The later is so lawmakers – unable to reach difficult budget or bill decisions – adjourn at the end of a general session, only to call themselves back into special session the next day and, thus, put off tough decisions day after day.

The governor’s power to call a special session, and set its agenda, is not changed.

Except, another part of the amendment says, if the governor determines at any time the state is going to run a deficit (fewer revenues than budget spending), then he can only trim spending across the board, AND he has to call the Legislature into a special session to deal with it.

The later issue goes way, way back, when in November of one year it was clear the state was running a deficit, but then-GOP Gov. Mike Leavitt refused to call lawmakers into special session to make budget cuts, saying he would handle it until the general session started in January.

Legislators didn’t like that Leavitt was refusing to call them into session and complained loudly about that decision.

 

More Stories
Curtis introduces state border reimbursement plan