
As it now appears, any Utah legislator can request, and then release to the press and public, what is known as a “constitutional note” on any bill, not just their own bill.
This is actually an amazing outcome that many of Utah’s veteran legislators a talking about quietly behind the scenes at the Capitol.
And it all comes about AFTER the GOP legislative majority did away with public constitutional notes on bills last year.
“O, what a tangled web we weave when first we practice to deceive” – Sir Walter Scott
You may recall that after Rep. Cheryl Acton, R-West Jordan, introduced a restrictive abortion bill this year, Rep. Karen Kwan, D-Salt Lake, asked for an opinion of legislative lawyers on the constitutionality of the bill – and then Kwan released the opinion, which says the Acton bill is likely unconstitutional.
Before GOP legislators last year did away with public constitutional notes from their own lawyers, such an opinion would have been put on the bottom of the bill – for all to see.
But the Republicans in the Legislature sometimes DON’T WANT the public and media to know that their proposed bills are likely unconstitutional – for that helps Democrats and others to kill the bill.
And it can even give ammunition to those against such a bill to argue with GOP Gov. Gary Herbert that he should veto such a bill, if it passes the House and Senate.
So we thought such unconstitutional opinions from the Legislature’s own attorneys would no longer be seen.
But, under attorney-client privilege, it now appears Democratic, even fellow Republican, legislators can request a formal constitutional opinion on ANYONE’S bill, and either release it publicly, as Kwan did, or leak it privately to the media or others.
The legal reasoning, I’m told, is complicated. And not just a little ironic for the GOP majority.
In this regard, lawmakers have put themselves in a constitutional bind, I’m told.
Several years ago they passed, and citizens approved, a constitutional amendment that puts into the basic document the Legislature’s own attorney.
The Constitution reads: “The Legislature may appoint legal counsel which shall provide and control all legal services for the Legislature unless otherwise provided by statute.”
UtahPolicy.com is told that such constitutional language means the attorneys in the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel have a constitutional duty regarding their legal work.
And that means attorney-client privilege is strengthened, i.e., the attorneys will uphold the private conversations between each attorney and each legislator.
And that, in turn, means that if a legislator asked a drafting attorney for the constitutional note placed on another lawmaker’s bill, then that note will be passed on (as a work product of the bill.) And then it is up to the non-sponsor “client” lawmaker whether to make it public or not.
In short, when a legislator asks for the note, they in effect are asking for an opinion from their own lawyer on the constitutionality of a possible law.
And, by duty, that opinion (which happens to be the note) must be given to that non-sponsor lawmaker.
However, if that non-sponsoring lawmaker then decides to leak that note to the media or members of the public, if the sponsor, or any other legislator, even a member of GOP leadership, asks the attorney which legislator was given the note, the attorney won’t tell who got it.
Again, attorney-client privilege.
Thus, in the case of a powerful Republican lawmaker wanting to somehow punish another Republican for leaking the note, or a Democratic legislator for leaking the note, that can’t happen – at least as I understand all of this.
Well, perhaps the GOP majority in either the House or Senate will just decide to adopt a new rule to keep the note secret to only the sponsor, or a rule that says the sponsor can be told which other legislators asked for the note.
Not so quick, I’m told.
The Legislature’s legal counsel is in the Constitution. And any rule contrary to what the counsel must do in regards to attorney-client privilege is far superior in law than a legislative rule – even if one were so adopted.
So, as it stands now, any legislator can ask their attorneys’ office for a constitutional note on another lawmaker’s bill(s) – as part of each legislator wanting to know an opinion on proposed legislation.
That must be given to the non-sponsor lawmaker. Who in turn can give that note to anyone else, including nosy reporters, either in a public or private manner.
And the sponsor can’t find out which fellow legislator got that constitutional note. Thus the sponsor, or any other legislator, can’t find out who leaked the note to the media or public.
I gotta say, I absolutely love this situation – a legal protection for the leaking of an otherwise private document to the media.
God bless the Utah Constitution, and what appears is the absolute legislative attorney-client privilege for legislators.
Whether they like it or not.
