
Will several thousand Republican county delegates this month change the tenor and functioning of the Utah State Republican Party?
The test will come over the next several weeks, as party organizing conventions are held in the 29 counties – and new at-large State Central Committee members are picked.
In what must be considered a quirk in the Utah GOP’s internal operations, it is county delegates – not state delegates – who pick the 100-or-so at-large State Central Committee members.
And a majority of those SCC at-large members often have the numbers in otherwise sparsely-attended Central Committee meetings to carry the day – adopt state GOP budgets, pass new bylaws, and otherwise lead the biggest political party in Utah.
Now, not only don’t Utah Democrats or independents care what the state GOP does, most of the 650,000 registered Republican voters in the state don’t care.
And in a better political world, they shouldn’t have to.
But the state Republican Party’s Central Committee has become a dysfunctional, petty, name-calling and 4th grade-acting group, which is on the verge of seriously – very seriously – affecting the political life of the state.
For all of us, Republican voters or not.
At stake in the big-population county GOP conventions this month – and at the May 4 state convention where a new party chair will be picked – is whether the largest party in the state falls into complete disarray.
Or whether with new Central Committee membership and a big win for Derek Brown as chairman can pull the party back to consensus, financial stability, and moving forward.
If not – should anti-SB54 golden boy Phill Wright win the chairmanship, and if many of the Gang of 51 get re-elected by county delegates to the State Central Committee – then who GOP voters can pick in primaries may be seriously limited.
UtahPolicy.com reports that GOP Gov. Gary Herbert, Republican leaders in the state House and Senate, along with former party chairs and others who in the past have had a settling effect on internal party politics, are coordinating efforts to block Wright and Gang of 51 Central Committee members’ elections over the next month.
They are doing so not to be petty or nasty or trying to be big brothers to disobedient current party bosses.
But trying to return some sense of objectivity, some reality-based political leadership.
Folks, the candidate dual pathway in SB54, adopted by lawmakers and Herbert in 2014, is here to stay.
In bankrupting the state party over anti-SB54 lawsuits, the right-wingers have seen the law upheld once by the Utah Supreme Court, by two federal court trials, by the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, and by the U.S. Supreme Court.
The law allows a candidate, not his party bosses/delegates, to decide whether he collects party voter signatures to get on the primary ballot, or takes the traditional caucus/convention/delegate route, or takes both routes at the same time.
But the Gang of 51 hate signature gathering from normal party voters.
They only like the delegate route.
Why?
Because their ilk has for years been the delegates – who, various polling shows – are more conservative than are Utah rank-and-file Republicans.
If Utah’s GOP establishment – if I can use that term – aren’t successful in getting more reasonable folks elected in county GOP conventions as new SCC members, and if Wright beats Brown, then the cancer inside the state GOP will just continue growing.
And we will see, down the road, the state party adopting bylaws that could:
- Kick signature-gathering candidates out of the Utah Republican Party.
This could include such “RINOs” as U.S. Sen. Mitt Romney, who survived the 2018 state GOP convention, but finished second to a relatively-unknown arch-conservative Utah House member. Romney gathered signatures to ensure his primary ballot placement, and wiped the floor there with the arch-conservative among GOP voters.
- Disadvantage any signature candidates in primary elections – including party leaders endorsing their convention-only candidates or denying signature-gathers’ names be on the ballot under the Republican Party banner.
- Party funds, as little as they are, being spent AGAINST signature-gathering candidates in primary races.
- It is not out of the realm of possibility that the state party under these anti-SB54 zealots could call signature-gathering candidates, or SB54 party supporters, into “hearings” where they would have to swear allegiance to all items in the state party platform, or face disciplinary actions.
Am I crying wolf?
Let’s hope we don’t have to find out.
Herbert et al. are going to county GOP conventions over the next few weeks with suggestions of SCC candidates who pledge to be rational and reasonable and help the state party get back on its feet.
Will the county GOP delegates listen and respond?
We’ll be watching.
