
Music has been a part of Utah’s culture and fabric since the state’s founding. It’s part of the reason why Sen. Orrin Hatch – my former boss – put such weighted emphasis on issues pertaining to local performers.
Unfortunately, the security of the state’s songwriters is now under threat from the Department of Justice, which is considering eliminating the 80-year-old consumer protection measures that have helped up-and-coming songwriters grow and thrive.
At an August event at the Hatch Center, entitled “Music Licensing in the 21st Century,” Makan Delrahim, head of the Department of Justice’s Antitrust Division,saidthat he would like the DOJ to re-evaluate the music industry’s antitrust agreements, known as consent decrees, quickly. In a recentinterviewon Utah’s KSL News Radio, Delrahim suggested that altering the decrees may be helpful to the “95-percent of the artists…who might be living paycheck to paycheck.” Nothing could be further from the truth, and Utah’s artists can attest to as much.
Because the overwhelming majority of popular music is licensed through one of two groups: the American Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers (ASCAP) and Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI), cartels that gained market domination by manipulating copyright laws long, long ago. In order to play music or allow for it to be performed in public, businesses need to buy licenses from ASCAP or BMI.
Without guardrails in place, their position as a duopoly controlling90-percent of music would give them the opportunity to charge exorbitant rates. This would certainly benefit the elite operating the music publishers, who would receive more revenue, but it surely would not help average performers. They are already struggling to get by due to the transparency problems at these very institutions.
So in 1941, the federal government came up with the DOJ music consent decrees, which have been protecting local musicians and businesses from abuse by requiring ASCAP and BMI to charge fair-market rates. The decrees have made sure everyone has come out a winner: ASCAP and BMI have kept their market share, businesses only need to negotiate with two institutions who cannot gouge them, and up-and-coming musicians have a plethora of venues to jumpstart their careers.
The music monopolies have paid close to $2 million in settlement fees for failing to comply with the decrees in just the last few years. If the DOJ gets rid of or weakens their restraints, they would happily go back to their price gouging, pre-World War II ways. Music executives and publishers would clean up but many small businesses that support live music would be forced to close. Utah’s consumers and performers would get the shaft.
This is not the first time in recent years that the consent decrees have come under fire; in 2015, the Obama administration made similar rumblings, so Sen. Mike Lee held a music licensing hearing that guided Obama’s DOJ in its decision to leave the agreements alone.
Lee is still chair of the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Antitrust, Competition Policy, and Consumer Rights. That subcommittee is holding its antitrust oversight hearing on Tuesday, Sept. 17. Utah’s senior senator needs to reserve some of the time at that hearing to ensuring Trump’s DOJ comes to the same, appropriate conclusion.
