
I’m asked nearly every day for my opinion about the impeachment of Pres. Donald Trump. Here are questions I’m frequently asked and, after watching way too many hours of impeachment hearings and floor debates, my answers.
The U.S. House has impeached the president. Was it justified? Absolutely not. As moderate Utah Congressman John Curtis stated, it wasn’t even a close call. Certainly, Trump is a flawed person and a flawed president. Certainly, his call with the new president of Ukraine wasn’t “perfect” as he has stated.
But that call and associated activities in no way rose to the level of impeachable offenses. Trump’s actions were not so egregious that he should be thrown out of office a little more than 10 months before he faces voters for re-election or defeat.
The 2016 election should not be overturned over questionable actions in which there was no victim and no negative result. Ukraine received the aid in a timely fashion. Ukraine didn’t conduct any investigation of Joe Biden and his son (even though such an investigation would be justified).
I’m old enough to have seen many presidents make many mistakes, act selfishly in their own political interests, do stupid things, act in partisan ways, and so forth. But those activities didn’t rise to the level of impeachment and neither does Trump’s actions. If you don’t like a president or his policies, vote him out of office. The House Democrats have severely dumbed down the solemn act of impeachment.
Should and will the Senate convict the president and remove him from office? The Senate trial will be messy, as has been the House process, but the outcome is preordained that Trump will be acquitted. Bottom line: Trump will remain as president and stand for election in 2020.
Congressman Ben McAdams was the only Utah member of Congress to vote to impeach. Did he cave to Democratic leadership pressure, and will his vote hurt him in his re-election? I take McAdams at his word that this was a very close call for him, but he had to vote his conscience and he believed the president should be removed from office. While there was, no doubt, subtle pressure from his fellow Democrats to vote in favor, I believe McAdams made up his own mind.
I believe McAdams’ vote will be a net negative for his re-election, but it won’t be the deciding factor. His voters are closely split on impeachment. The memory of impeachment will somewhat die away 10 months from now. Much more important will be the Republicans’ ability to recruit a really good candidate against McAdams and get out the Republican vote, especially in Utah County. Had Republicans run a stronger grassroots campaign in 2018, McAdams would not be a member of Congress.
What will be the overall impact on the 2020 elections in Utah? Again, it will be a net plus for Republicans, but other factors will be much more important.
What will be the impact on the 2020 presidential election? The national polls are turning against impeachment and removal for office, especially in swing states. Thus, impeachment will not hurt the president, but it won’t guarantee him a victory. Much more important will be the eventual Democratic nominee, which is still very much unknown, and the state of the economy next fall.
I believe it will be a very close election, decided by a handful of swing states. But if Trump behaves himself somewhat reasonably, and the Democrats nominate an arch-liberal candidate like Bernie Sanders or Elizabeth Warren, Trump will have an advantage.
