Gov. Gary Herbert says he just has a few issues left to hammer out with the feds about his "Healthy Utah" alternative to Medicaid expansion before he can take the plan to Utah lawmakers. Our "Political Insiders" aren't so sure he'll win approval for the plan before the 2015 Legislature.
Just 38% of Republicans and 46% of Democrats think he has a better than 50% chance of getting "Healthy Utah" approved by both the feds and lawmakers before the 2015 session next January.
Democrats are much more pessimistic than Republicans. 23% of Democrats and 15% of Republicans think he has no chance at all of getting "Healthy Utah" approved by both groups.
Selected anonymous comments:
"The very components that might make the feds approve it will likely make the legislature reject it."
"The issue is the House. The Senate will sign off no problemo. While Lockhart doesn't have the same leverage she used to, other prominent members of the House will fight it just as hard."
"I think the Federal government is more likely to be flexible than some of the ideologues in the legislature. Crazy thought, when you think about it."
"It's a 50/50 thing. He'll probably get federal approval, with some adjustments demanded by the feds, but getting legislative approval, especially while Becky is still Speaker, is tougher — I give that a 20% chance of success."
"This is no longer a question of whether or not it is a good idea, good for the state or good for our economy. It is a question of how long do we have to wait before those in the greatest need can get in to see a doctor."
"The work requirement will make the Healthy Utah plan unacceptable to the feds. That part should not be part of it. People need health insurance whether or not they can find a job."
"It's a bad plan. Let's just take the federal money and do right by our citizens!"
"Herbert is a master negotiator."
"The work requirement was turned down in PA and then PA accepted the rest of the deal. The Gov's plan would be approved federally without the work requirement, but I am fearful the Utah Legislature will not approve. Too bad, it's a good deal and we've already lost a lot of the potential benefits."
"Unless the Governor were to call a special session, it is obvious that the Legislature won't 'approve' anything before the 2015 session, however, I do believe that the Governor will ultimately receive approval from both Washington and the Utah Legislature."
"Half a chance for a half-baked half program. He would have done better to expand Medicaid and take the Federal money rather than giving it to other states."
"He needs to find an alternative to the work requirement to make any headway with the feds."
"There is a good chance the Legislature approves it. Obamacare, and by extension, the medicaid expansion included in it, just isn't the favored political punching bag anymore. It doesn't fire up the Republican base like it has before, that position probably now belongs to immigration. Fewer Republicans are using Obamacare as an issue to attack Democrats this midterm season. Moreover, some Republican governors are reconsidering their choice of rejecting the expansion initially, but I don't know of any that accepted the expansion and regretting their decision. The business community supports it, the healthcare industry supports it, it just seems to make sense for most people."
"The Governor doesn't want to give the Speaker a platform to beat him up."
"There will be lots of chest thumping, but at the end of the day the Legislature will approve his plan with very few changes (probably most done in verbose intent language)."
"We shouldn't expand medicaid. We should do something to fill the gap untill the feds fix the mess they created. The Governor doesn't have the answer."
"The feds will likely approve some form of the plan but the Legislature refuses to budge when it comes to helping needy Utahns, they prefer catering to their narrow, close-minded base."
"This needs to be done now, but there are too many pieces, players and opinions to make it happen before the session."
"This should be a no-brainer. Utah gets to use money our taxpayers have already paid in the way Utah decided it should be used. Lives blessed will be blessed."

