Same-Sex Marriage in Utah Still a Divisive Issue Despite SCOTUS Ruling

Most Utahns, a recent UtahPolicy poll shows, are now going to have to accept – if begrudgingly – federal court rulings on something they oppose – same-sex marriage.

Monday, to the surprise of U.S. Supreme Court experts, the high court refused to hear this year five different appeals from states where federal appellate courts ruled their ban on same-sex marriage unconstitutional.

Peggy Tomsic, the lead counsel for the same-sex couples in Utah who had won in federal court and again in the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, said in an emotional press conference Mondaymorning that the high court’s refusal to hear Utah’s case means same-sex marriage is legal in Utah, and that couples married in the brief window last December must have those marriages legally recognized, and that same-sex couples (she is one) who wish to have adoptions of children within their marriages will get those adoption rights.

But all these new rights and privileges by Utah same-sex couples go against the majority will of Beehive State citizens.

A recent UtahPolicy poll conducted by Dan Jones & Associates found that 61 percent of Utahns oppose same-sex marriage.

 

Oddly enough, among those same folks 58 percent believed that ultimately Utah would lose its appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Tomsic said that in her legal opinion that is exactly what happened Monday, when the high court refused to hear the appeals from five different states – who had lost their anti-same-sex marriage cases in their federal appeals court decisions.

While it is possible that at some later date the high court will hear a ban on same-sex marriage, “it will be difficult to get this toothpaste back in the tube,” she said.

In essence, the high court would have to rule that the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution DOES NOT protect same-sex couples in marriage, rule that now-legal same-sex marriages are unlawful, and disenfranchise tens of thousands of same-sex marriage couples.

That would be a very difficult thing for the high court to rule, she added.

Gov. Gary Herbert expressed disappointment in the decision by the high court during a hastily called press conference on Monday morning.

"While I believe this is a state's rights issue, and states should have the right to define marriage, we are a nation of laws and Utah will uphold the law," he said.

Herbert also sent out a letter to state agencies ordering them to immediately begin conducting business recognizing all legally performed same-sex marriages.

Attorney General Sean Reyes said he hoped the Supreme Court would have taken up one of the appeals. "They have decided the law for Utah and other states in the 10th Circuit."

Both Herbert and Reyes were clearly flummoxed by the decision and were not sure what the path forward would bring, but they urged Utahns to come together to start the healing process on this divisive issue.

"This has been and will continue to be an emotional issue," said Herbert. "I encourage all people of Utah, regardless of their personal beliefs, to treat each other with respect and kindness."

What exactly this means for conservative Utah legislators, who greatly favor banning same-sex marriage, is unclear.

Will some legislators still try to restrict for same-sex couples some privileges now given to heterosexual married couples in the state?

More specifically, will there be a political backlash against gay rights advocates who want the Legislature, through a statewide law, to outlaw discrimination against gays and lesbians in employment and housing?

That law, supported by leaders of the LDS Church in Salt Lake City and other local governments, has been rejected time and again in the Legislature.

But it likely will be introduced again in the 2015 Legislature by Sen. Steve Urquhart, R-St. George.

Perhaps anticipating a U.S. Supreme Court decision relating to same-sex marriage, over the weekend at the General Conference of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Apostle Dallin Oaks, a member of the ruling Quorum of the Twelve, gave a talk in which he encouraged faithful Mormons to graciously accept any legal rulings on same-sex marriage.

Oaks is a former justice on the Utah Supreme Court – which has not heard the same-sex marriage law here.

That’s because several years ago the Utah Legislature put on the ballot a state constitutional ban on same-sex marriage.

That passed with around 65 percent of the vote – so the Utah Supreme Court, controlled by the state constitution, almost certainly would have upheld the voter-approved amendment.

So proponents of same-sex marriage sued in federal court, and last December a federal judge in Utah ruled the state law unconstitutional – the first such decision in the United States.

However, the Utah amendment went further. It not only disallowed same-sex marriage, it also said the Legislature could not pass any law that in any manner would give marriage rights (without using the name “marriage”) to same-sex couples.

Oaks said Mormons should be kind and understanding in the face of the same-sex marriage issue.

But there are clearly strong feelings among the Mormon community on this issue.

Jones found that 88 percent of “active” Mormons oppose same-sex marriage.

Besides the political backlash against Urquhart’s antidiscrimination bill, Monday’s ruling could hurt many Democratic candidates in November’s election, now just a month away.

Candidates like Democratic AG George Stormont opposed GOP Attorney General Sean Reyes’ appeal of the 10th Circuit’s ruling saying Utah’s same-sex law is unconstitutional.

In his poll, Jones found that 87 percent of Utah Republicans oppose same-sex marriage.

But in a huge political shift, he found that 79 percent of Utah Democrats favor same sex marriage.

However, 54 percent of Utah political independents oppose same-sex marriage.

Thus there is a clear demarcation – Republicans and independents oppose same sex marriage, Democrats favor it.

 

Even if some Democratic candidates for the Legislature or county offices oppose same-sex marriage, will they be able to disassociate themselves from the majority of Utah Democrats in order to grasp some GOP or independent votes come November?

The high court’s refusal to hear same-sex marriage – and so make same-sex marriage legal in Utah – could be a real impact on close state and local races for Democrats – for in swing districts Democratic candidates will need a few GOP votes, and certainly many independent votes, to win their races next month.

For Democratic candidates who favor same-sex marriage, the issue could quickly become politically toxic.

More Stories
Do we call them ‘wackos’ or ‘dumbos’? – Bernick and Schott on politics Ep. 348