There is ample cause for Republicans to be concerned about the 2016 race. Hillary Clinton essentially has a lock on her party’s nomination while the Republican “front runners” are in a five-way tie with plenty of challengers behind them.
So Hillary will be amassing her resources for the general while the GOP candidates are spending theirs on a bloody primary.
Moreover, the fact that Mitt Romney lost virtually every swing state in 2012 is a gruesome portent of the future.
But surrounding this gloomy cloud is a silver lining that Republicans can cling to: the candidate with the silver hair tends to lose.In the last six presidential elections, the younger candidate has won five times.
|
Year |
WINNER |
Birth year |
LOSER |
Birth year |
Spread |
|
2012 |
Obama |
1961 |
Romney |
1947 |
14 |
|
2008 |
Obama |
1961 |
McCain |
1936 |
25 |
|
2004 |
Bush 43 |
1946 |
Kerry |
1943 |
3 |
|
2000 |
Bush 43 |
1946 |
Gore |
1948 |
-2 |
|
1996 |
Clinton |
1946 |
Dole |
1923 |
23 |
|
1992 |
Clinton |
1946 |
Bush 41 |
1924 |
22 |
The only time in modern politics that an older candidate beat a younger one was 2000, where the age difference was negligible and, yes, Al Gore won the popular vote. Furthermore, those elections where the winning candidate was significantly younger than the loser (the Clinton and Obama elections) were blow-outs.
This phenomenon could be an example of modern-media ageism, where the younger (and presumably more attractive, telegenic) candidate has an edge based on superficial qualifications. Or it could indicate a legitimate sense that the highest office in the land requires a stamina and vitality lost in later years. Most likely it’s a combination of the two.
But regardless, this trend bodes well for Republicans in 2016 because all the candidates are younger than Hillary Clinton.
|
Year |
DEM |
Birth year |
GOP |
Birth year |
Spread |
|
2016 |
Clinton, H |
1947 |
Carson |
1951 |
4 |
|
1947 |
Bush, J |
1953 |
6 |
||
|
1947 |
Huckabee |
1955 |
8 |
||
|
1947 |
Paul |
1963 |
16 |
||
|
1947 |
Walker |
1967 |
20 |
||
|
1947 |
Cruz |
1970 |
23 |
||
|
1947 |
Rubio |
1971 |
24 |
While the spread with Ben Carson and Jeb Bush is negligible, everyone from Rand Paul down has an age advantage comparable to the ones enjoyed by Obama and Clinton over their vanquished opponents.
Now of course the thing about presidential politics is everything is a rule until it isn’t. Democrats couldn’t win without a candidate from the South – until they did. As Ohio goes, so goes the nation – until it doesn’t. Hillary will (most likely) be the first-ever female at the top of the ticket, so that’s a new variable in the equation.
It remains to be seen if running an older candidate can trump the trend of voters favoring younger candidates or if a female candidate is even more vulnerable to this preference – but this trend is something to give Republicans hope about winning next year.