In an op-ed, Sen. Orrin Hatch details the ways Senate Democrats have progressively poisoned the judicial confirmation process over the past 30 years, dating back to their treatment of Robert Bork and Clarence Thomas in the 80s. Liberals are crying foul over the Senate GOP’s deployment of the “nuclear option” Thursday to clear a path for the confirmation of Supreme Court nominee Judge Neil Gorsuch, but Hatch points out that it was the Democrats, led by Harry Reid, who pioneered the nuclear option in 2013 on behalf of Barack Obama. (Reid even boasted last October about how he’d laid the groundwork for eliminating the filibuster for SCOTUS nominees.)
Writes Hatch at TIME:
Having borked Bork, smeared Thomas, instigated the filibuster for lower court nominees when it was in their interest, filibustered Alito and then eliminated the filibuster for lower-court nominees when it was in their interest, Senate Democrats boldly argued this week that Republicans should throw up our hands and allow them to block Gorsuch — an unquestionably qualified nominee with broad support from across the legal community.
History leaves no doubt that, if the shoe were on the other foot, Senate Democrats would never have allowed a partisan filibuster of a Democratic president’s Supreme Court nominee. I have participated in this process for 40 years, during every combination of partisan control in both the Senate and White House. I have seen the confirmation process degrade from cooperation to, now, all-out partisan conflict.
That is not a direction that is good for the country or for the institutions of the Senate and the judiciary. I am relieved that we stopped Senate Democrats from continuing to poison the confirmation process and that Judge Gorsuch will get an up-or-down vote. It is unfortunate that the Senate rules had to be changed to ensure that. But that was the choice my Democratic colleagues made by attempting the first successful partisan filibuster of a Supreme Court nominee in American history.
