The 13 Republicans vying to win the delegate nod at the June 17th nominating convention in Utah’s 3rd District are in a tough situation.
Candidates can’t seem to be too cozy with Trump and his policies, especially since Trump carried CD3 in 2016 with only 47.2% of the vote, while “never Trump” candidate Evan McMullin scored 24.5%. On top of that, Utahns don’t like Trump that much. 50% of Utahns have an unfavorable opinion of the president, while 54% disapprove of his job performance.
Despite that apparent discomfort with Trump, two of the leading Republican candidates to replace Rep. Jason Chaffetz are having trouble finding places they disagree with Trump on policy proposals.
Sen. Margaret Dayton, R-Orem, and Sen. Deidre Henderson, R-Spanish Fork, were guests on the “Beg to Differ” podcast this week with hosts Bryan Schott and Mike Winder.
Dayton said she would not be a reliable vote for the Trump administration, instead preferring to evaluate his policy proposals based on their constitutionality.
“We need to remember I’m not running to be part of the executive branch, I’m running to be part of the legislative branch, and there are people in the legislative branch with whom I have common ground,” said Dayton. “I’ve visited with and made friends with in the freedom caucus and would look for like-minded people in those groups with which to align myself.”
Henderson says her priority would be protecting the interests of voters in the 3rd District.
“First, foremost, last and always I will be a voice for the people in the 3rd Congressional District,” says Henderson. “I will represent them. My job and goal will not be to represent the White House, not to represent any faction in Congress, not to represent any leadership, it will be to represent the 3rd Congressional District. Inasmuch as those policies and proposals are in line with the values and the goals and the voice of the people and our principles, I’ll be supportive.”
However, both Dayton and Henderson struggled to name any specific policy proposals on which they differed with President Trump.
Dayton said she had some reservations about President Trump’s travel ban which prohibits travel and immigration from several Muslim-majority countries.
“I’m not sure that’s the best way,” said Dayton. “My approach would be a little softer than his right now.”
Henderson, could not name a single policy area where she disagreed with President Trump.
“There’s probably a few little things, but the big things I’m in line with,” she said.
Dayton said she supports Trump’s approach to foreign alliances as well as his promise to bolster the military and address the immigration problem.
“He has required other countries with whom we have international agreements to pay their share of the organization. I’m pleased he is talking about protecting our borders because that is one of the roles of the federal government is our national safety. I’m pleased he’s talking about improving payment and support to the military. Those are the things which I could also agree.”
Henderson points to Trump’s plan to reform the tax code as one of his policy proposals she can get behind.
“We gotta do tax reform. That’s on the top of his agenda. I think we’ve gotta do that. The last time we had any meaningful tax reform was the year Michael Jackson starred in Captain EO; it was before Ronald Reagan told Gorbachev to tear down the wall. It needs to happen. We wonder why we’ve got corporations fleeing the country. We’ve got one of the highest corporate income taxes in the industrialized world. We’ve got 74,000 pages of tax code. We need to lower the rates and simplify the tax code and make things better for people and businesses to flourish in this country. I think that’s a good item and we’ve got to get that done.”
However, those policy proposals from Trump are not on the top of the list for 3rd District voters. A recent UtahPolicy.com survey found that 16% of 3rd District voters said education was their top priority, while 11% said health care. Only 4% said immigration was their #1 issue while that same percentage picked taxes.
