Bob Bernick’s notebook: Herbert keeps his promise

Bernick Mug 01

Congratulations to GOP Gov. Gary Herbert for vetoing this week SB123, a bill that would have set up a special election process in a U.S. House vacancy that bans candidate signature gathering.

Herbert’s action likely won’t be overturned by the Republican-controlled Legislature, reports UtahPolicy.com Managing Editor Bryan Schott.

The governor’s veto of SB123 continues his general support of SB54 – the 2014 compromise law that provides a dual pathway by any candidate to his or her party primary ballot.

Under SB54, a candidate can gather a set number of voter signatures to get on the primary ballot, or he can go through his party’s county or state delegate convention, or he can take both routes at the same time.

A number of candidates, including Herbert himself, have taken the signature-gathering route to ensure they make it to the primary election.

Herbert gave his policy reasons for his SB123 veto in a letter to legislative leaders, which you can read at the bottom of this column.

They are sound arguments, I believe.

But let’s look beyond them for a moment and consider political ramifications if Herbert had not vetoed the new bill (and it became law):

= Any waffling on SB123 – which dumps the SB54 signature route – would indicate a softening of his pro-SB54 stands.

Several years ago, in his monthly KUED Channel 7 TV press conference, Herbert promised to veto any attempt to repeal SB54. You can read the 2017 UtahPolicy.com story on Herbert’s pledge to veto a repeal of SB54 here.

A politician can always change his mind. But poll after poll shows that more than 60 percent of Utahns like the dual pathway law and don’t want it repealed – leaving party delegates the only route to make a primary election where voters get a say in picking a nominee.

Thus, Herbert’s veto of SB123 shows he’s keeping his promise on sticking with the SB54 candidate route options.

= Herbert has said he’s not running for re-election in 2020. He’s already won three governor elections, and going for a fourth would set a Utah gubernatorial record.

Almost certainly, Lt. Gov. Spencer Cox will run for the top job next year, although Cox has not yet announced. Expect a number of candidates in the GOP field.

Cox is the official state elections officer, and he runs the Utah Elections Office which overseas all elections in the state.

So, it’s been Cox’s job to enforce SB54, which he has done faithfully – often to the displeasure of a small group of Utah Republican Central Committee members known as the “Gang of 51.”

The gang has, after finding a financial backer, kept the party lawsuits against SB54 going, and going, and going, all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, which earlier this month refused to hear the final appeal.

The lawsuits have basically split and bankrupted the party – but that is a whole other story.

Herbert, the titular head of the state party, has called time and again for the party to heal, and for the right-wing nutcakes (my word, not his) to accept the failed lawsuits’ outcomes and accept SB54 and move on. Little signs that will happen.

But the political reality is that Herbert strongly supports Cox’s run to replace him.

And Cox, as the main institutional defender of SB54 via the Elections Office, would be in real trouble if next year he had only the delegate/convention route to the GOP gubernatorial primary election.

Herbert, after all, finished second to archconservative Jonathan Johnson in the 2016 GOP state convention – only to swamp the challenger in the primary election on his way to winning a third governor’s race.

By vetoing SB123, Herbert shows he will be sticking by SB54 all the way through his final term.

Cox can plan on getting to the 2020 GOP primary ballot via gathering 28,000 voter signatures – assuming Cox doesn’t win the convention outright, should he take both routes.

So, while Herbert makes good policy arguments to veto SB123, he also has, let us say, personal political reasons for doing so, as well.

Two birds with one stone is certainly OK, as long as both birds are worthy of being knocked down.

And keeping the SB54 signature-gathering route for special elections – for all elections — is certainly a worthy goal.

More Stories
CYBER24: Biz and Gov’t a cybersecurity dynamic duo?